Building a $200K Newsletter With Just 2,000 True Fans With beehiiv
From Pricing To Licensing, Discover How Matt Brown Created Value That 2,000 Loyal Fans Couldn’t Resist Paying For
Table of contents
Situation
After being laid off in 2020, journalist Matt Brown launched Extra Points, a newsletter covering the business side of college sports—a hyper-specific niche underserved by traditional media. Starting from scratch, he focused on delivering high-value, original reporting to an audience that deeply cared about the topic.
Challenge
Brown needed to:
- Monetize a small but loyal subscriber base
- Avoid dependence on ads and social algorithms
- Offer more value than free or mass-market alternatives
- Find scalable revenue models beyond just paid subscriptions
- Replace Substack, which took a 10% cut and lacked advanced tools
Solution
Brown migrated to beehiiv, enabling him to:
- Keep more revenue with zero platform fees
- Easily manage tiered pricing and email automation
- Launch creative products like the Extra Points Library and ADS4000, a niche video game
- Explore institutional licensing deals with universities
- Focus on premium journalism that readers would pay for
Results
- Scaled to 27,000 subscribers, with 2,000 paying
- Generates $200,000+ annually from a mix of subscriptions, licensing, and products
- Secured $3,000/year licensing deals with universities and athletic departments
- Developed a high-trust, niche audience around expert reporting
Related Case Studies
How Important, Not Important Reached 280+ Issues by Turning Science News Into Action
A weekly science newsletter helping readers move from information overload to real-world impact
How beehiiv’s Top 4 Recommendations Drive Publisher Growth
How beehiiv publishers drive high-intent subscriber growth without paid acquisition
How The Publish Press Reached 130,000+ Subscribers with 45% Open Rates
Expanding from YouTube to newsletters to educate creators at scale
